In December, The Flatlander did a mini fundraiser to do its first investigation. About $600 was raised, which allowed me to hire John Loeppky, a disabled journalist and former editor-in-chief of the Carillon, the University of Regina’s campus newspaper. He has written for CBC, Maclean’s, the FiveThirtyEight and a long list of other publications.
Readers, who voted on Twitter and Facebook, said they were interested in The Flatlander looking into a systemic issue specific to Saskatchewan and Manitoba, so John and I got together for a brainstorming session late last year.
As a journalist, John’s niche areas he covers include writing about disability and independent media. And what I learned from meeting with John is that disabled people can be limited by the very government systems intended to provide them support.
For instance, government disability payments cap how much money a disabled person can save or earn at a job, which makes it impossible to save for a house, schooling, a holiday, or an emergency fund, which in turn makes it difficult to transition off government assistance.
Local, independent, in-depth.
Our Prairie stories.
For this issue of The Flatlander, John investigated the policies of Manitoba’s and Saskatchewan’s provincial auto insurers—Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI) and Saskatchewan Government Insurance (SGI)—and learned how they can make life challenging to someone who is disabled in a vehicle accident.
Once injured, you enter MPI’s or SGI’s bureaucratic system that can decide how many hours you work or even what kind of vacuum you can buy.
If disabled in an accident, you lose not only some of your physical independence from injury, but you also lose, to some extent, your freedom to choose what is best for you as John finds out.
Below is the story John wrote thanks to reader generosity.
“They were making me the problem and the problem was my car, you know what I mean? Like, I was looking for a mechanic and they sent me to a doctor,” said Winnipeg’s Debbie Patterson.
She is currently in the process of filing a human rights complaint against Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI) because of the proverbial hoops she’s been faced with while trying to adapt her vehicle to suit her disability.
Patterson is looking to add hand controls, which would allow her to accelerate and brake without having to use her feet, if and when her multiple sclerosis impacts her driving ability.
However, doing so became a challenge because of policies she says are rooted in systemic ableism, a word used to describe discrimination or bias against those with disabilities.
This was particularly frustrating for her because the 2013 Accessibility for Manitobans Act (AMA) was supposed to remove barriers like this that disadvantage disabled people.
“[I] had to really do some digging to figure out who would put hand controls in my car,” she said. “And then I talked to this guy at a mobility place who said, ‘No, we can’t do it until you go through this process with Manitoba Public Insurance.’ And I thought he must be wrong.”
After she confirmed the process with her occupational therapist, Patterson began what she describes as a number of forms, unnecessary medical exams, argumentative phone calls and a series of letters.
According to MPI, in order to have hand pedals installed, an individual has to complete an assessment to determine if the driver has the functional and cognitive ability to be able to operate a vehicle and to see what type of modifications to the vehicle may be required.
Once this assessment is completed the report is sent to MPI.
“We are able to then work with the customer and the community occupational therapist to determine what type of vehicle would best suit their needs and which could be modified,” said Brian Smiley, a spokesperson from MPI, in a Feb. 23 email to The Flatlander.
Patterson thinks the MPI process is unnecessarily prohibitive.
“I think if you’re choosing to spend $1,000 to put hand controls in your vehicle, you’re doing it out of an abundance of caution, you’re doing it to be a safer driver,” she said. “It’s not like it makes you a more dangerous driver.”
She doesn’t understand why MPI would restrict access to hand controls.
“It’s not like people are going to abuse them,” she said.
Smiley said the processes are in place, in part, to ensure MPI is being fiscally responsible.
However, he noted MPI reviews informal customer feedback from its case managers to see if the system can be improved.
Patterson has yet to be able to put hand controls in her vehicle because to do so requires an assessment she feels puts her at a high risk of being exposed to COVID-19 as she would have to travel to a hospital for an exam and share a car with an assessor.
Allen Mankewich is a Manitoba-based wheelchair user who has driven since he was sixteen.
He says while there is legislation like the AMA, more could be done to help people, like Patterson, by adding a clear complaints and enforcement arm to the provincial legislation.
“If you compare it to the Americans with Disabilities Act, which has very clear guidelines, and very clear penalties, the legislation that we have in Canada, either provincially or federally, seems to be very lacking, comparatively.”
Mankewich said the wider attitudes about disability make inaccessibility issues, like the one Patterson faces, all too common.
He said filing human rights complaints to address these problems can be long, arduous and expensive.
“You don’t automatically get a lawyer who’s going to fight your case for free,” said Mankewich.
On the Saskatchewan side of the border, Blake Lamontagne is a Regina-based wheelchair user, who found himself arguing with Saskatchewan Government Insurance (SGI) about buying a particular type of vacuum that would be easier to use, thus improving his quality of life.
“I’ve got a Roomba now, but I mean it took me like four years to get one,” said Lamontagne. “They eventually came around.”
Tyler McMurchy*, a spokesperson for SGI, said, in a March 2 email to The Flatlander, each claim is adjudicated on its own merits.
“We do our best to provide a decision promptly, however at times more investigation, review and due diligence is required,” he said.
McMurchy said Saskatchewan’s Automobile Accident Insurance Act dictates what criteria must be met for funding decisions to be made.
“Is the specialized mobility device safe for the customer? Does it have supporting literature to deem it safe and reliable,” said McMurchy. “We also obtain the opinion of a medical consultant with the requisite expertise to review literature.”
Lamontagne said a rulebook, like the Insurance Act, means too many presumptions are made throughout the process.
“Just because something works for me, or I asked for something and it worked, doesn’t mean that it’s going to work the same for you. Right? It’s got to be more personalized,” he said.
However, McMurchy said SGI’s processes are important to ensure they are treating their customers fairly and consistently.
Jessie Staples, from Lloydminster, was paralyzed in a vehicle accident as a teenager.
As a quadrapaliegic, Staples found it difficult to get a job after completing a commerce degree at the University of Saskatchewan. Like most recent graduates, she also didn’t have much experience and her disability limited what jobs she could do, as well as which ones she was perceived to be able to do, an issue that affects many disabled Canadians.
Offered a part-time job, Staples jumped at the opportunity and was soon offered full-time hours.
The challenge came when she realized she needed to reduce those hours.
“The work-life balance wasn’t giving me enough time to keep up with the added time it takes being quadriplegic,” she said. “In order to cut back, SGI was like, ‘Well, we’ve decided, based on the fact you’ve been working full time that you can work full time. So you have to go through a medical evaluation in order to prove basically that you need to cut back, which is a bit of a hassle.”
Payments she receives from SGI because of her injury are meant to top up her income after being disabled, and can be a wage replacement. If Staples had to reduce her hours because of her disability, SGI would have to pay her more.
Sorting out this issue with SGI included a medical evaluation. In the meantime, she continued to work full-time to avoid an awkward situation with her employer.
“If you don’t live with a disability or know anyone who is disabled, it’s hard to understand what we deal with,” she said.
Five stories from Manitoba you may have missed
- An MLA is disheartened after resolution honouring women politicians devolved into ‘hurtful’ remarks.
- Winnipeg’s Assiniboine Park Zoo will begin vaccinating animals against COVID-19.
- Turns out, an only child has 10 siblings.
- A 96-year-old WW2 veteran was honoured by the Polish government in Winnipeg.
- New legislation will help Manitoba potato and root crop growers find buyers.
Five stories from Saskatchewan you may have missed
- Regina’s Zarqa Nawaz, creator of Little Mosque on the Prairie has a new show.
- Saskatchewan’s Internet Child Exploitation unit handled a record number of cases in 2021.
- A Saskatchewan man shares his experiences while in Ukraine during the Russian invasion.
- Northern Sask. broadcaster calls Hockey Night in Canada in Cree.
- The Saskatchewan forestry sector sets a new sales record in 2021.
Photo of the week
Until next week…
- Help grow The Flatlander by forwarding this email to a friend.
- Subscribe. Was this email forwarded to you, and you want more? Sign up to receive this newsletter.
- Read back issues of The Flatlander.
- Ask. Is there more about this topic you’d like to learn about in a follow-up issue of The Flatlander? Just reply to this email to inquire.
- Share your part of the Prairies. Do you have a cool photo from Saskatchewan and Manitoba and want it to be featured as a Photo of the Week? Send it along by replying to this email.
- Suggest future topics you think should be explored in future issues of The Flatlander by replying to this email.
- Follow The Flatlander on Instagram, Facebook and Twitter.
Thanks for reading, and kind regards,
*Note: An earlier version of this newsletter misspelled Tyler McMurchy’s name wrong. The previous version spelled his name McMurphy.
Our Prairie stories matter too.
The Flatlander takes a closer look at the stories that unite us, and make us unique, in Saskatchewan and Manitoba.
Will you help us tell our stories?